Review: ‘A Dog’s Way Home’ wins viewers’ hearts despite confusing storyline
Strong ideas executed poorly in heart-warming film
The drama/adventure movie, “A Dog’s Way Home” is sure to win people’s hearts. Director Charles Martin Smith creates a unique theater experience by filming the entire movie in the perspective of a pitbull named Bella, who is trying to find her way back to her owner Lucas (Jonah Hauer-King). During her 400 mile journey, Bella encounters obstacles and makes memorable friendships. This film shows all dog and cat lovers there is no bond like one shared between a beloved pet and its keepers.
Throughout the 96 minute film, viewers follow Bella and experience her love, discipline, loyalty and nostalgia towards Lucas. A main conflict in the movie was Bella’s breed because pitbulls are not legal in Denver, the setting of the movie. Smith beautifully depicts pitbulls as being kind and delicate creatures rather than an aggressive breed. Smith also briefly features a gay couple who love and take care of Bella, which is important to mention due to the controversy people from the LGBTQ+ community face; although he knew he would receive backlash with this choice, it was refreshing to see people of different races, backgrounds and lifestyles to be included.
One of the movie’s flaws were the poorly written characters. Because the film revolves around the point of view of Bella, the audience saw only what Bella would see. This made it extremely hard for the audience to become attached to any particular character, even the main protagonists of the movie. Although the acting was exceptional, the actual script was incohesive.
Although the film was rated PG, parents argued it should be raised to PG-13. This is because it contains scenes which may be disturbing to the audience, especially for younger viewers. “A Dog’s Way Home” shows a dead body for a couple minutes, so fair warning to those who are sensitive to graphic material.
The majority of the movie takes place in the forest with an animated cougar. The computer generated imagery (CGI) made it difficult to enjoy the movie because the cougar looked so fake and unbelievable.
Apart from the poor animation and characters, the actual storyline was difficult to keep up with because of the constant going back and forth from side characters to the cougar. It didn’t help that we did not get any background with Lucas in the time spent apart. By the time Lucas and Bella reunite, more than two years have already passed and the audience is left with unanswered questions as to what specifically changed.
Though Smith had a unique idea having a dog as the main character, the storyline was all over the place and made it extremely hard for the audience to keep up or even become invested in the movie. Despite this, it was a success at being a ‘tear-jerker.’ The film deserves 3 out of 5 stars for being diverse and including multiple cute dogs. Bella’s great acting and discipline did not go unnoticed; it made the movie more enjoyable because the filmmakers used a real dog rather than a CGI version. Had the characters been more believable and the script more developed, this film definitely would’ve earned 5 out of 5 stars.
Linda Maroney • Mar 17, 2019 at 12:16 AM
Great ideas was not executed poorly.
Most always criticise a great movie.
Nothing confusing at all.
A,heartfelt homeward bound type of movie only better
Linda Maroney • Mar 17, 2019 at 12:11 AM
Nothing confusing about this storyline absolutely brilliant.
Dan • Mar 11, 2019 at 6:58 AM
I loved this film. I felt the human characters were well developed. Anymore and they would have distracted the focus of the animal characters. The way Bella described the man dying in the film was quite beautiful. I cannot fault this movie
Patty Smith • Jan 19, 2019 at 4:41 PM
BELLA definitely was NOT a pit bull… and if she was, she was shown to be very kind and loving. I have owned a pit a Long time ago and Bella was just a “cur” or “Heinz 57”.. :). Great movie.
Patty Smith • Jan 19, 2019 at 4:40 PM
I didn’t believe any of the film was CG until I asked my husband said it had to be… that a cougar and a dog would not lie down together. I thought the script was great and the characters highly developed… 2 1/2 years later Lucas had married…. You see the couple in bed at the end and their wedding picture show several times. I hated that the man that Bella saved did not want his dog back. I am a huge dog lover and enjoyed the movie a lot. I thought it was great and give it FIVE STARS. Yes, the kids who found the body should have called the police first. I understood it all and did not feel like it was hard to keep up with.
Sandy • Aug 15, 2023 at 5:21 AM
Yep. If you find this movie hard to keep up with, stay away from films like Inception. Lol